Symptoms and structural causes

Join

Step 1 Select a dimension of ex/inclusion Open

Selected: Relational

Exclusion is relational as both a process and an outcome. As a process, exclusion is about the rupture between individuals, groups and societies. As an outcome, it is about the end result of this rupture when the excluded cannot enjoy shared opportunities and are in a position of relative deprivation as compared to the rest of the society. In other words, both the process of exclusion and its result are about differentiated and unequal relations between the excluded and mainstream society.

 

Many adopt this approach in their policy actions. The World Health Organization, for example, has used it since 2008 to inform the work of its Commission on Social Determinants of Health. The body developed a policy analysis framework that examines exclusionary processes in four dimensions – social, economic, political and cultural – as drivers of health inequalities. The approach proved useful by shedding light on how and why the excluded have differential access to the resources required to protect their health, and by, subsequently, revealing ways to redress the situation.

 

The diagnosis and tackling of this relationality is amongst the major policy merits of ex/inclusion. Four markers can assist inclusive policy work in this regard.  

Step 2 Select an Inclusive Policy Marker Open

Selected: Equality of opportunities and outcomes

Inclusive policies should be well placed to deal with both equality of opportunities (or lack thereof) and persistent structural factors that affect equality of outcomes. Two key points elaborate on why and how it can be done.  

Step 3 Select a Policy Design Consideration

Selected: Symptoms and structural causes

To deliver sustainable outcomes, measures do not only redress symptoms and manifestations of inequalities and exclusion (e.g. lack of income, education or healthcare) but also cover their deep and structural causes (e.g. discrimination, differentiated power relations, lack of access to resources, lack of representation). Not factoring the two leads to narrow and discretionary policy measures that, even if initially successful, may not bring long-lasting change. The need is for double-track interventions that focus on both (a) provision of services for short-term amelioration of market and societal imperfections, which could be qualified as policy quick wins to address symptoms of exclusion, and (b) addressing the longer-term and deeper goal of inclusive development, which are those that tackle structural inequalities. 

 

Explore concrete examples of the map. 

No policy example in this category yet
SUBMIT EXAMPLE

Join