We are not beings, we are becomings
Benjamin Freud - 11 March 2022
While the UNESCO report came out with much fanfare and generated much excitement, its most powerful consideration has received surprisingly little attention. It’s not that the authors haven’t put this consideration front and center—on the contrary—yet somehow it has eluded the spotlight. Perhaps this is the nature of the game. Proposing a new social contract that redefines the purpose of education as a common good that should involve everyone, everywhere coming together to repair a damaged planet requires a soft touch. The report had to be edgy enough to pique curiosity, but not so much so that it scares people off. This is the first step of a rallying cry.
This cry might just end up muffled because the report underemphasizes what makes it special; one little letter in a 160-page report. That is letter is the “s” in the word futures that sits in its title. This is not only the story of the many different futures we may have. This is the story of the many different futures we will carve for ourselves, which might converge if we begin with inner work. From this might come a common set of ethics that will allow us to share futures—and it starts with making sure the planet has a future.
The report opens the door to this, but doesn’t walk in. It flirts with post-humanism—calling us to unlearn the arrogance of humans and “re-wild” curriculum—but shies from explicitly adopting a living systems paradigm, which recognizes that all life has its own unique essence and exists as a nested whole within larger wholes. Each of these wholes is an ecosystem onto itself and works with an infinite number of other ecosystems in a dynamic of reciprocal development. To create “futures that are shared and interdependent” means to recognize that we are all wholes with a unique essence. Essence is what makes you, you. You cannot be replicated.
we thrive as communities,
Essence is not static. It is the energy that drives our learning and actions, that shapes what it means to flourish. Yet from flourishing as individuals, we thrive as communities, as ecosystems. From the many flowers emerges a garden, which also has essence. When essence (that energy!) is unleashed and liberated, we become who we are, to borrow from Nietzsche. When it is diminished or suppressed, we become less who we are. Essence reaches its highest potential when we engage in actions in which we are completely immersed, through which we lose all sense of time and space, when we feel we are who we are, with no separation between us and our actions.
We are perpetually at the nexus of past and future, ever changing through the infinite interactions with everything in the universe, interactions that are not events but processes: there is no beginning and no end to the interactions, there is no separation between us and the universe. We are enfolded within it. We are the flowing water of a river, not the immobile stone around which the current passes.
This isn’t woo woo spirituality. This is the quantum theory. This is also the teachings of many ancient wisdoms. It is also biology: every day 330 billion of your cells are replaced. You are not the same cells you were 100 days ago!
then we are not beings, we are becomings
If we are not static, if we are processes— flowing water rather than immobile stones—that unfold at the point when past and present meet, then we are not beings, we are becomings. We are not nouns, we are verbs. Understanding that everything is change is the key to understanding that we are impermanent, that we are nodes within the fabric of the universe.
This is why pausing on the UNESCO report proposing shared futures is critical, but if we are not careful, we may miss the true power of what the report offers.
If each of us has a unique essence that is flowing, we need a vision to direct the course of the flow—what do we want to become? This vision is personal and nothing connects our many respective visions or our futures unless we do the inner work of self-reflection to understand what we want become and make choices toward realizing our becoming. The inner work is key because it opens the door to consciousness, to social consciousness.
How do we make sure that the personal visions become shared visions to create shared futures? The UNESCO report is an invitation, but there is no model for the inner work. Inner work is personal.
Yet there is a way to connect many visions while honoring our individual essences as they chart the courses of our becomings. Living systems paradigms help us understand we are nested within larger wholes and so while we may be unique, we are also something bigger. Just like your heart is whole yet belongs to a cardiovascular system that itself belongs to you, you belong to a community, to a species, to all life on earth. Since we are nested wholes, ecosystems within ecosystems, there is no separation. We are our hearts like we are our communities.
It therefore makes as little sense to damage the larger ecosystem because that would mean damaging ourselves and this is the key to creating shared visions, shared futures. This awareness is an awakening, a generation of social consciousness that extends beyond the human and into the natural world.
This awareness is the next step in us becoming as a collective, together. Ethics is the glue that keeps the individuals together, and there is one specific ethical question that guides our choices and actions:
How do my actions contribute to the thriving of the ecosystem?
If we do the inner work to see ourselves not as beings but becomings, if we understand that we are nested wholes (ecosystems) within larger wholes, then we live and act to contribute to the thriving of all life. That is our shared futures. Respecting our unique essences, coming together to realize we are all part of one universe.
Benjamin Freud is the co-founder of Coconut Thinking and is the Whole School Director of Learning and Teaching at an International School in Thailand. He holds a Ph.D. in History, an MSc in Education, an MBA, an MA in International Relations, and a BA in International Affairs.
Cite this article (APA format)
Freud, B. (11 March 2022) We are not beings, we are becomings UNESCO Futures of Education Ideas LAB. Retrieved from https://en.unesco.org/futuresofeducation/ideas-lab/freud-becomings.
Cite this article (MLA format)
Freud, Benjamin. "We are not beings, we are becomings". UNESCO Futures of Education Ideas LAB. 11 March 2022, https://en.unesco.org/futuresofeducation/ideas-lab/freud-becomings.